forum.rugby.it

BixBeiderbecke ha scritto:Scusate se torno sulla solita, vecchia, trita questione.
Però, senza fare nomi, uno sport che utilizza un pallone dalla forma più regolare rispetto al pallone che usiamo noi, potrebbe imparare qualcosa anche dalla partita FRancia - Scozia.

Con tutte le questioni sulla buona fede degli arbitri e sulle designazioni, sui sorteggi o cose del genere, oggi, nel rugby, un TMO irlandese con la sua decisione ha in pratica consegnato il 6 Nazioni alla Francia a discapito dell'Irlanda. Chapeau.

quoto quoto

BixBeiderbecke ha scritto:

rasen64 ha scritto:Giusto,anche perchè la meta era chiara e limpida

Però se sei ironico dovresti mettere le "faccine". Già ci sono fin troppi malintesi, qui.

Se non sei ironico, prova a leggere il commento scozzese alla partita (o guarda nuovamente l'azione, se puoi)

Dov'è il commento scozzese? Qualcuno lo può linkare?
Bisognerebbe anche vedere in base a che criterio il TMO assegna la meta o no. Lì l'evidenza assoluta non c'era, ma secondo me c'era una forte probabilità: palla in area di meta nelle mani di Vermeulen e Mignoni libero che spinge giù. E' vero che c'era il braccio di uno scoz. Secondo me la meta c'era. Non so se a rigore di regolamento il TMO avrebbe dovuto assegnarla o no...

bella responsabilità eh?

Nell'impossibilità di essere sicuri, credo che sia sufficiente la "forte probabilità".
Un raggruppamento in progressione cade in area di meta con il pallone saldamente in mano di un giocatore avversario: anche se non si riesce a vedere il momento in cui tocca terra credo che si debba concedere la meta.

Lamont appeals yellow card


The Scottish Rugby Union have appealed against the yellow card shown to Sean Lamont during Saturday's RBS 6 Nations defeat by France.

The Northampton winger was sent to the sin-bin for 10 minutes midway through the second half after he was adjudged to have committed a late tackle on France centre David Marty.

But the SRU have contested the yellow card on the grounds of mistaken identity - because the culprit was Lamont's brother Rory.

Sean Lamont said after the game: "They got it a bit wrong. I've got blond hair, my brother's got dark hair.

"I'm not going to say what I really think because I'll get myself in trouble.

"But I suppose it's a snap decision the officials have to make. Things happen quickly on the pitch."

The winger scored a try in a 46-19 defeat as France clinched the championship after overtaking Ireland on points difference in the dying seconds.

Meanwhile, Scotland scrum-half Mike Blair has undergone surgery to the edge of his collarbone and shoulder joint.

He was injured in Edinburgh's Magners League victory over Llanelli Scarlets in January.

Following repair to the damaged tissue, Blair will be in a sling for three weeks before a two-month rehabilitation period.

Blair said: "This is the first time I've had a major injury in seven years and I've found it frustrating having to sit and watch Edinburgh and Scotland and not be involved.

"I'm just looking forward to getting through the rehab period so I can get back to playing again as soon as possible."

France impress Lamont


With Scotland's RBS 6 Nations campaign over after a 46-19 defeat at the hands of champions France, thoughts are beginning to turn to the World Cup.

And winger Sean Lamont feels France could be good enough to challenge tournament favourites New Zealand for glory on home soil.

"As we've just seen, when the French go at it, they can really fire," said wing Lamont after a game in which France needed Elvis Vermeulen's late try to seal the championship.

"With the World Cup, it depends who is playing well at the time, but I still put my money on New Zealand."

Coach Frank Hadden was also upbeat, saying: "Before the start of the Six Nations, we had 14 injuries and everyone thought we were in disarray.

"We ended up coming here disappointed we did not have a chance to win the title.

"We should have won our last two home games (against Italy and Ireland) and that would have given us a chance of winning the tournament."